Catering York Pa

My Favorite Deli- Catering Menu

Having an event, birthday party or meeting? Dawn’s My Favorite Deli has what it takes to satisfy you and your guests.
Don’t see something from the menu to suit your needs? Don’t worry! Fill out the form on our contact page, let us know what you had in mind and we’ll get back with a price within 24 hours!

Sandwich Trays

Sandwiches served on assorted breads.
Mix and match any of our favorite sandwiches to create a platter that is perfect for your special occasion.

8 Sandwiches$89

2 Turkey Lite, 1 Deli Club, 1 Chicken Salad, 2 Roast Beef and Jack, 1 Ham and Cheese, 1 Corned Beef and Swiss

12 Sandwiches$125

2 Turkey Lite, 2 Deli Club, 2 Tuna Salad, 1 Corned Beef and Swiss, 2 Roast Beef and Jack, 2 Chicken Salad, 1 Ham and Cheese

15 Sandwiches$140

2 Turkey Lite, 2 Ham and Cheese, 2 Tuna Salad, 1 Corned Beef and Swiss, 2 Roast Beef and Jack, 2 Deli Club, 2 Chicken Salad, 2 Shrimp Salad

25 Sandwiches$225

4 Turkey Lite, 3 Ham and Cheese, 3 Tuna Salad, 3 Corned Beef and Swiss, 3 Roast Beef and Jack, 3 Deli Club, 3 Chicken Salad, 3 Shrimp Salad

Party Subs

Our party subs are available in either:
3′ (serves approx 12 people) or 6′ (serves approx 24 people)

3′ or 6′

American$52.00 $104.00

Italian$65.00 $130.00

Turkey Lite$69.00 $138.00

Breakfast Trays

Early Morning Favorites:

(Assorted Muffins, Croissants, Bagels and Cinnamon Rolls)

Serves Price

Small10-15 $75.00

Medium15-20 $95.00

Large20-25 $125.00

Bagel Tray:

(Assorted Bagels with Cream Cheese)

Serves Price

Small10-15 $55.00

Medium15-20 $64.00

Large20-25 $79.00

Veggie Trays

Freshly cut Broccoli, Cauliflower, Carrots and Celery, Garnisheed with Cherry Tomatoes

Serves Price

Small15-20 $55.00

Medium25-35 $70.00

Large40-50 $115.00

Party Trays

All trays include Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, White American and Swiss Cheese. Your Choice of olives or cubed cheese in the center

Serves Price

Small6-10 $69.00

Medium12-16 $85.00

Large20-25 $115.00

X-Large30-35 $130.00

Wrap Trays

Delicious variety of Meat and Cheese combinations rolled in an assortment of Wraps

Serves 8$92

2 simply Roast Beef, 2 Ham and Swiss, 2 Club, 2 Turkey and Cheese

Serves 15$155

2 Simply Roast Beef, 2 Ham and Swiss, 2 Italian, 2 Tuna Salad, 2 Club, 2 Turkey and Cheese, 2 Chicken Salad, 1 Shrimp salad

Combination Veggie and Snack Trays

Freshly cut Broccoli, Cauliflower, Carrots & Celery along with two types of Cubed Cheese, Sweet Bologna and Ham
Dip Included: Ranch, Dill or Green Pepper

Serves Price

Small15-20 $64.00

Medium25-35 $82.00

Large40-50 $115.00

Snack Trays

All trays include Cubed Cheese, Bologna and Ham

Serves Price

Small15-20 $75.00

Medium25-35 $95.00

Large50-60 $130.00

Fresh Fruit Trays

Summer Fruit
(Only Available April thru November)

Fresh Watermelon, Cantaloupe, Honeydew, Pineapple and Grapes

Serves Price

Small10-15 $65.00

Medium15-20 $80.00

Large20-25 $92.00

Deli Salads

All Salads are freshly prepared
24 hour notice is greatly appreciated
Approximately four servings per quart.

Price Per Quart

Macaroni13.95

Potato, PA Dutch Style13.95

Dijon Potato Salad13.95

Broccoli Cauliflower$14.95

Spaghetti Salad13.95

Greek Pasta Salad14.95

Italian Pasta Salad13.95

Fresh Fruit (Seasonal)Market

Party Salads

Our Delicious Salads are great as a side dish or as a meal for a lighter alternative.
(Includes two dressings)

Mixed Greens (Small)8-12 $72.00

Mixed Greens (Large)16-20 $88.00

Spinach Salad (Small)8-12 $85.00

Spinach Salad (Large)16-20 $110.00

Deluxe Veggie Tray

Freshly cut Broccoli, Cauliflower, Carrots and Celery, Green and Red Peppers, Cucumbers, Cherry Tomatoes and Radish Roses

Serves Price

Small15-20 $65.00

Medium25-35 $85.00

Large40-50 $125.00

Dessert Trays

Assorted Dessert Trays:

(Assorted Desserts, Cheesecake, Brownies, Cookies and Dessert Bars

Serves Price

Small10-15 $65.00

Medium15-20 $75.00

Large20-25 $95.00

Cookie Tray:

Homemade Assorted Cookies:
Chocolate chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Sweet Dream, Peanut Butter, Chocolate and Coconut Chew

Serves Price

Medium10-15 $58.00

Large15-20 $72.00

Chocolate Lovers Tray:

Chewy Homemade Brownies in Four Varieties:
Peanut Butter, Walnut, Cream Cheese and Peppermint

Serves Price

Medium10-15 $70.00

Large15-20 $81.00

Desserts

Cheescakes

Traditional (Seasonal)$32.00

Chocolate Chip$35.00

Chocolate Peanut Butter$35.00

Chambord$37.00

Amaretto$37.00

Double Layer$37.00

Cakes

Carrot$32.00

Chocolate$30.00

Chocolate Pecan$32.00

Sour Cream Pound Cake$18.00

Orange Poppysead w/ Orange Glaze$19.00

Three-Layer Cakes

Coconut$38.00

Spice$38.00

Black Walnut$35.00

Yellow29.00

Other Desserts

Sheet CakeAvailable Upon Request

Frosted Brownies$28.00/pan

Pecan Squares$30.00/pan

Tandycakes$30.00/pan

DB+